GRADE YOUR TITLE

Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door scores 8/10 in the verdict of The Games Market editorial team.

Paper Mario, paper worlds to discover on the Cube!
Once Upon a Time

Paper Mario, paper worlds to discover on the Cube!

by Simon LaroccaMarch 28, 2025

In a chaotic era where remakes, reboots, and returns, some improbable and others necessary, are the order of the day, talking about Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door, known here as Il Portale Millenario, means truly opening a portal connected to the past. A past in which the avant-garde grandfather of the Nintendo Switch, the unbreakable GameCube, gave the gaming community an absolute masterpiece.
E and those who know me know that I do not use this word lightly. I had already talked some time ago about the return on Switch of the adventure among the folds of paper and origami of the Mario brothers, but there are still so many things to say and so many peculiarities that have remained in my paper notes, just to stay on theme, and that I would like to share here with you.
Cenni historical notes and where to find them, here: the game was released in 2004, just before Christmas, as per Nintendo tradition when it comes to series that are particularly prolific and important to it. The Thousand-Year Door is in fact the second installment in the paper worlds saga and follows the line of the role-playing spin-offs of the quintessential plumber brothers. It was one of the greatest critical and commercial successes for the GameCube, a pairing that is not so obvious considering that just a couple of years earlier, Nintendo had to make up for the commercial flop (but not with the public, and I am one of them) of Eternal Darkness, an insane title that, I promise you, will eventually land on these shores.
La feature that immediately catches the user’s eye, then, concerns its graphic style: we find ourselves inside a paper micro-universe, where characters, places, various settings and, of course, the two protagonist brothers have all been shaped into a new form; if you love origami and paper dioramas that often adorn Eastern temples during the festivities in the Land of the Rising Sun, then you know what we’re talking about. The sense of wonder felt in the first minutes of play lasts for almost the entire duration of the main adventure, in which we will face the saga’s historic enemies, such as the sentient Goomba mushrooms and not only that, all with a turn-based combat system.
A true revolution, as I mentioned just a moment ago, anticipated by some RPG prequels that are still worthwhile today and definitely worth revisiting.
La plot revolves around the disappearance of the usual Peach, the love interest par excellence of the mustached Italian who, needless to say, immediately rushes off to look for her to save her from any enemies in the shadows and, while we’re at it, to get hold of the Crystal Stars which, according to legend (not just any legend, but “the” legend), are the keys to unlocking a passage, the thousand-year portal, and finally finding a hidden treasure, exactly what Peach, in her Eva Kant version, was trying to find at all costs. On their path, the Crossed will appear for the first time, a brand-new organization of villains in the multilayered world of the Mario Bros, and I won’t add anything else because I’d say I’ve spoiled quite enough and that is never a good thing.
La trama, let’s be honest, is not Paper Mario’s strongest aspect, but that’s not the point: as only the Kyoto house knows how to do, it’s in the obsessive care for gameplay and its exceptional ideas that The Thousand-Year Door hit the accelerator twenty years ago, skidding into the hearts of fans (I didn’t mention Mario Kart by chance!): turn-based battles are never boring, moreover the timing system implemented effectively allows for a great deal of variability and a broad range of skill and move customization. And if we add the fact that Mario can transform into a little paper airplane when needed… 
Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image
The levels are impressive (the castle in particular, not to mention the boss fight with the dragon) and the game is absolutely hilarious at times: often you’ll find yourself smiling at the little skits that Mario and his adventure companions will put on for the player audience, all seasoned with original, carefully crafted, and very colorful level design: did I already tell you that the settings are all made of paper, right?
To conclude, Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door will give you the chance to rediscover the masterpiece that brought glory to the Nintendo GameCube.
And if you don’t believe me… well, I wrote it, so the proof is in the pudding.
Game Cover
8

Pro

Twenty years and not showing them: despite the beautiful remake on Switch, the original still holds up well

A graphic sector that enchants and refreshes the usual 2D dynamics we were used to

Fun turn-based combat system and decent strategic management on the field

Contro

Not everyone will appreciate the old-school role-playing-style turn-based system, a nice change from previous Mario games where the height of planning was grabbing a blinking star

Fluctuating difficulty, not always as balanced as in other Nintendo-branded iterations

Complete
45,74 €
New
129,95 €
Graded
607,81 €
author

Simon Larocca

Mi chiamo Simon Larocca, e sono un videogiocatore, collezionista e amante della cultura pop in tutte le sue forme. Vado al cinema ogni volta che posso, leggo da quando porto gli occhiali, quindi da sempre, e ho la passione per lo storytelling in tutte le sue forme, così dirompente da farla diventare una professione. Ma come direbbe Doc di Ritorno al Futuro, non ci sarebbe presente se non si guardasse al passato con rispetto e ammirazione, ed è il Simon bambino di più di trent’anni fa, anno più anno meno.

TGMGrading

Grade your titles

Inspection, sub-grades, seal and display case: every grade comes with the method behind it, written down in full.

Marketplace

See what is for sale

Graded pieces only: grade and label in plain sight on every listing, so you know exactly what you are buying.