GRADE YOUR TITLE

Maui Mallard in Cold Shadow scores 8/10 in the verdict of The Games Market editorial team.

Maui Mallard in Cold Shadow! Unlikely Shirts, the Art of Ninjas, and Disney as You've Never Seen It!
Once Upon a Time

Maui Mallard in Cold Shadow! Unlikely Shirts, the Art of Ninjas, and Disney as You've Never Seen It!

by Simon LaroccaJune 7, 2025

The enchanted castle of Disney, a company founded by that visionary trickster “Uncle Walt,” has over time become an iconic symbol of magic and fantasy, from the animated films we grew up with to the visionary stories passed down through new technologies.

Se ripercorro il river of time of my adolescence, permeated by the cheerful memories and dense afternoons spent tinkering so as not to lose the last life available, I can only bring to mind gems like Castle of Illusion for Sega or the dark and intriguing Darkwing Duck on NES. However, the title I want to talk to you about today has nothing to envy in those mentioned above: I am referring to Maui Mallard in Cold Shadow, known to us as Donald in Maui Mallard.
Flashback, 1995: MegaDrive and Super Nintendo battle each other on store shelves with shoot ’em ups, fighting games with hadouken-like vibes, and excellent platformers in which you jump, run in spinning mode, and the player is not spared the classic embarrassment of choice. Good times, right?
Maui Mallard was introduced into this cauldron of succulent titles by Disney’s department devoted to video game productions, Disney Interactive, with a cutting-edge desire to dare that, regrettably, we will hardly see again in the new millennium: after its debut on Sega, the title then landed in quick succession on Nintendo, PC and also on the Kyoto house’s handheld. But let’s return to our private detective with the features of Donald Duck, but who is not Donald Duck, an issue we will come back to.
Teatro dell’avventura main is the tropical island where the home idol, Shabuhm Shabuhm, which sounds more like the onomatopoeia of the ninja blows dealt by Maui (ninja? We’ll come back to that too, don’t be impatient!), has mysteriously vanished into thin air.
Maui Mallard will have to jump, shoot, dodge deadly bullets and sneaky attacks, and get through colorful levels designed in a truly inspired way by the developers: just think of the native village level, with the blue waterfalls in the background and an overall maniacal attention to detail, both graphic and sound.
Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image
The latter area, moreover, sees the presence at the musical helm of none other than Michal Giacchino, the legendary composer of unforgettable film and television soundtracks, such as that of the TV series Lost: in Maui Mallard, Giacchino manages to make the game’s exotic atmospheres his own, without distorting the driving liveliness that distinguishes it.
Il risultato è una colonna sonora allegra e frenetica, che ben si sposa con l’anima platform del titolo e la componente action dettata dalla trasformazione all’occorrenza di Maui in una macchina da guerra ninja. Detective privato di giorno e combattente ninja di notte, Maui Mallard was conceived as an original character with his own lore, despite being the spitting image of Donald Duck, as you may have noticed. Why? Because initially the title was Donald in Maui Mallard (even in Italy the reference is to Donald Duck and not Maui) leveraging, of course, the strong media appeal of the grumpy duck we all know, even though it later became clear that the two characters were different and that Donald Duck was not playing the character of Maui, because the latter existed on his own.
Il gameplay of the title is mainly based on the dual playable mode that can be activated, both of which are necessary in order to advance from level to level: thanks to his training in the noble art of ninjutsu, our duck sheds his Magnum P.I.-style Hawaiian shirt and puts aside the long-range bug-shooting gun to don the guise of the ultimate cool warrior: as a ninja, Maui can jump higher and climb to otherwise unreachable spots, while with the aid of his Bo he can fight hand-to-hand with the numerous local enemies. 
The whole thing blindfolded, because you know, if you're a ninja you also have to be full of yourself and act tough, otherwise there’s no fun in it.
A title certainly worth (re)discovering, which will put your manual skills to the test and deserves to have its place of honor in your collection.
Game Cover
8

Pro

Maui Mallard’s duality is fascinating. Donald Duck’s alter ego turned detective with ninja abilities: there was enough there to create an entire world

The levels are traversable not only by “side-scrolling,” but also by exploiting the verticality of their architecture, with doors, passages, and so on: fluid gameplay and full of secrets to discover, what more could you want?

Ninja Maui with the eye bandage is so cocky that you can’t help but love him

Contro

Rather straightforward and sparse plot, there is no real characterization of the characters present: not a fundamental detail in a 1995 platformer perhaps, but one that would have added more to the title

It would have deserved a sequel, which was announced at the end of the game, because the character was solid

Complete
105,56 €
New
264,00 €
Graded
559,83 €
author

Simon Larocca

Mi chiamo Simon Larocca, e sono un videogiocatore, collezionista e amante della cultura pop in tutte le sue forme. Vado al cinema ogni volta che posso, leggo da quando porto gli occhiali, quindi da sempre, e ho la passione per lo storytelling in tutte le sue forme, così dirompente da farla diventare una professione. Ma come direbbe Doc di Ritorno al Futuro, non ci sarebbe presente se non si guardasse al passato con rispetto e ammirazione, ed è il Simon bambino di più di trent’anni fa, anno più anno meno.

TGMGrading

Grade your titles

Inspection, sub-grades, seal and display case: every grade comes with the method behind it, written down in full.

Marketplace

See what is for sale

Graded pieces only: grade and label in plain sight on every listing, so you know exactly what you are buying.