GRADE YOUR TITLE
The Black Box beats the grade
Grading

The Black Box beats the grade

by The Games Market RedazioneJuly 17, 2026

Heritage Showcase 44347, July 2026: 131 Nintendo lots from the NES to the Nintendo 64, a Super Mario Bros. in Wata 6.0 that is worth triple a 9.4 and the highest median among the Showcase sales of the year. Nine charts and three tables to read the market for the Black Box and the first releases.

The auction: the heart of Nintendo collecting

Heritage Auctions’ Showcase 44347, closed on July 16, is dedicated to the first four Nintendo generations: NES, Super Nintendo, Game Boy and Nintendo 64, with a few forays into Game Boy Advance and the Japanese catalog. It is not a Signature: no six-figure records, but 131 lots for a total of 229,664 dollars, an average of 1,753 and a median of 1,313, the highest among Heritage’s six Showcase sales of 2026. One note for context: Heritage is the major Texas auction house, prices are in dollars, the lots are almost all US editions, and the buyers are mostly American. We are reading it from Europe because the United States remains the benchmark market for video game collecting.

The catalog has three souls. Sixty-three NES lots, including twelve first-production Black Box complete with box and twenty certified prototypes; thirty-one Super Nintendo lots; twenty-seven among Game Boy, Game Boy Color and Advance, with thirteen Pokémon of which six are Japanese. As always, we have reconstructed the auction lot by lot: title, platform, certification and sale price of all 131 pieces are in the attached spreadsheet.

Table 1 · The figures summarizing session 44347. Values inclusive of the buyer’s premium.
Table 1 · The figures summarizing session 44347. Values inclusive of the buyer’s premium.

The performances: the flattest pyramid of the year

The top lot is worth just 4% of the take, the top three 11%, and the top ten 28%. No 2026 Heritage session has such a light peak: 72% of the money sits outside the top ten. It is an auction without superstars and with a huge body, exactly what is needed to read current prices.

Chart 1 · Share of total revenue by lot groups, from left: the first lot, lots from second to third, from fourth to tenth, all the others.
Chart 1 · Share of total revenue by lot groups, from left: the first lot, lots from second to third, from fourth to tenth, all the others.

The range between one thousand and two thousand dollars is the home of this auction: 64 lots out of 131, nearly half the list and 38% of the takings. Only four lots finished below five hundred dollars, two prototypes and two minor titles; none exceeded ten thousand. Seven lots between five and ten thousand dollars, the best Black Box and the Japanese Pokémon, make up 22%.

Chart 2 · Number of lots by award bracket; the thresholds in dollars separate the brackets. Above each point, the bracket’s share of revenue.
Chart 2 · Number of lots by award bracket; the thresholds in dollars separate the brackets. Above each point, the bracket’s share of revenue.

The typical lot costs more on Game Boy Color than on NES. The Game Boy Color, seven lots almost all Pokémon, has a median of 2,000 dollars; the Game Boy Advance is at 1,938, the Nintendo 64 at 1,875, the Super Nintendo at 1,438, the Game Boy at 1,375. The NES, with 63 lots, closes at 1,188: it is the deepest platform and, precisely for that reason, the one with the most affordable pieces.

Chart 3 · Median award by platform with at least three lots; in parentheses the number of lots. The price of the typical lot, not the record one.
Chart 3 · Median award by platform with at least three lots; in parentheses the number of lots. The price of the typical lot, not the record one.

The records: a 6.0 at the top of the ranking

$9,063 for a Super Mario Bros. in Wata 6.0: the lowest score in the top ten is the most expensive lot at the auction. The reason is all in the box: Matte Sticker, first production 1985, the very first print run of the title that launched the NES in America. In the same session, a Super Mario Bros. in Wata 9.4, intermediate production with hangtab, stopped at $3,500, and a 7.0 second production at $2,750. Three complete copies of the same title, three prices that follow the variant and not the score.

Chart 4 · The ten highest bids, on a logarithmic scale. Titles in purple, consoles and other objects in magenta.
Chart 4 · The ten highest bids, on a logarithmic scale. Titles in purple, consoles and other objects in magenta.

$9.063  Absolute record · Lot #80052. Super Mario Bros., Wata 6.0 CIB, Matte Sticker, first production. NES, 1985. The most worn copy in the top ten and the most valuable.

$8.750  Secondo · Lotto #80109. Pocket Monsters Midori, VGA 85 Unopened, Small UPC. Game Boy, 1996, Japan. The green version of the first Pokémon, the one that was never released in the West.

$8.125  Third · Lot #80108. Pocket Monsters Ao, VGA 90 Unopened, Store UPC. Game Boy, 1996, Japan. The blue version, sister of Midori.

Table 2 · The fifteen most expensive lots of the session, by hammer price.
Table 2 · The fifteen most expensive lots of the session, by hammer price.

The Black Box. The twelve titles from the American launch of the NES, the black boxes from 1985 and 1986 complete with box, are worth a total of $30,164, 13% of the auction, with a median of 1,625. Wild Gunman at 7,813, Golf at 4,500, Mach Rider at 3,126 and Soccer at 3,000 make up the backbone of the top fifteen. At the end of the list, Hogan’s Alley in PSA 8.0 at 538 dollars reminds us that even among the Black Box titles there is a hierarchy.

Among the sagas, Pokémon is first with 13 lots for $47,344, 21% of the auction and a median of 2,750. Six of those lots are Japanese and are worth $29,250 on their own: the first Japanese generation in VGA is the highlight of the session. Mario follows with ten lots for 27,125, the first-production black boxes fetch 30,164; Castlevania, Kirby and Donkey Kong remain below five thousand.

Chart 5 · Total value awarded by series, top seven; in parentheses, the number of lots. “Black Box” groups the twelve launch titles of the NES.
Chart 5 · Total value awarded by series, top seven; in parentheses, the number of lots. “Black Box” groups the twelve launch titles of the NES.

The same title, different prices: three Super Mario Bros., three productions

The auction lines up three complete copies of Super Mario Bros. for NES, all certified by Wata, with grades of 6.0, 7.0, and 9.4. The market has ranked them in reverse order of grade.

Table 3 · Three Super Mario Bros. and two Pokémon Red: the production variant, and the seal, matter more than the grade.
Table 3 · Three Super Mario Bros. and two Pokémon Red: the production variant, and the seal, matter more than the grade.

The first production with Matte Sticker is worth 2.6 times the intermediate-production copy in 9.4. The grade measures condition; the variant measures rarity, and for historical titles rarity carries more weight. This is confirmed by the Pokémon Red pair: the sealed second-production copy in Wata 9.0 costs 5,000 dollars, while the complete first-production copy in PSA 9.2 stops at 2,625. Here it is the seal that makes the difference: between a CIB and a sealed copy of the same title there is almost a factor of two.

On the NES, the rule has a statistical exception: the 28 complete-in-box titles have a median of 1,406 dollars, the 20 sealed ones 1,219. It depends on the catalog, not on the format: the CIB items in this session are mostly Black Box and first-production hangtab, the sealed ones are late titles with the oval sticker. The scatter of votes shows it clearly: the empty circles, the complete copies, are distributed at the same prices as the filled circles.

Chart 6 · Each point is a lot: grade on the horizontal axis, price on a logarithmic scale. Filled circles are sealed copies, open circles are complete in box. On the left the PSA, Wata, and CGC scale; on the right the VGA scale. The colors indicate the grader: PSA purple, Wata magenta, CGC periwinkle, VGA deep purple.
Chart 6 · Each point is a lot: grade on the horizontal axis, price on a logarithmic scale. Filled circles are sealed copies, open circles are complete in box. On the left the PSA, Wata, and CGC scale; on the right the VGA scale. The colors indicate the grader: PSA purple, Wata magenta, CGC periwinkle, VGA deep purple.

Niches and surprises: prototypes, cereals and a strategic guide

Twenty prototypes at list price. Certified prototypes are the cheapest block in the auction: twenty lots for 16,618 dollars, median 719. The Wata Pro slabs of Turtles in Time and Zombies Ate My Neighbors for Super Nintendo fetch 1,875 and 1,500; the CGC NG cartridges of NES are almost all between 550 and 875. Unique code, common-title price: the market pays for the box, not the development.

The cereal box. The factory-cut of the Nintendo Cereal System, the 1988 Ralston package with the Nintendo Power offer, in VGA 85+ fetches 1,625 dollars: more than a sealed Kirby’s Adventure. And the Player’s Guide of Super Mario 64 in CGC 9.8, white pages, brings in 3,250, the eleventh auction result ahead of all sealed Super Nintendo copies. Printed Nintendo paper is officially certified collector’s material.

Japan costs more than America. Thirteen Japanese-edition lots are worth 35,912 dollars, 16% of the auction, with a median of 1,750 versus 1,313 for the US lots. It’s not just Pokémon: Akumajō Dracula for Famicom Disk System in CGC 9.2 goes for 1,750, Super Mario USA in VGA 85+ 1,250.

The grades: four stamps in balance

It is the most balanced auction of the year on the grading front. PSA certifies 50 lots and 36% of the proceeds, VGA 31 lots and 28%, Wata 29 lots and 25%, CGC 20 lots and 10%. Each organization has its own territory: PSA on complete Black Box sets, VGA on Japanese items and consoles, Wata on sealed U.S. releases, CGC on prototypes, where it certifies fourteen lots out of twenty, almost all with the No Grade designation. Only one lot went through without a stamp.

Chart 7 · Awarded value by grading body, with share and number of lots; the gray slice represents uncertified lots. In the center, total revenue and number of lots.
Chart 7 · Awarded value by grading body, with share and number of lots; the gray slice represents uncertified lots. In the center, total revenue and number of lots.

The reading for TGM. Four entities with similar stakes and different specializations mean that the buyer must know how to read four scales: the decimal scale of PSA, Wata and CGC, and the centesimal one of VGA. A Super Mario Bros. 6.0 that beats a 9.4 says the rest: the certification stamp attests to the condition, but the value is determined by the copy’s documentation. This is the principle on which TGMGrading builds its own method.

The origins: the NES makes up 44%

The NES is worth 101,353 dollars across 63 lots, 44% of the auction. The Super Nintendo follows with 47,481 dollars across 31 lots, the Game Boy with 40,699 across 15: the portable platform has fewer pieces but more expensive ones, thanks to Japanese Pokémon. Game Boy Color, Advance and Nintendo 64 close between 7,000 and 16,500 dollars. U.S. editions make up 82% of the total, Japan 16%, and British and European editions less than 3%.

Chart 8 · Awarded value by platform, with amount and number of lots; the area is proportional to the value. The box with the dash groups the smaller platforms and lots without a platform.
Chart 8 · Awarded value by platform, with amount and number of lots; the area is proportional to the value. The box with the dash groups the smaller platforms and lots without a platform.

The comparison: the most expensive showcase of the year

Lined up, the nine Heritage video game sessions of 2026 tell the story of two markets. The three Signature sales, 7452 in March, 7453 in June, and 7454 in August, move from two to five million dollars with averages between 6,000 and 32,000. The six Showcase sales, from January to September, stand between 98,000 and 230,000 dollars with medians between 938 and 1,313. This is the richest of the six by revenue and the first by median: 1,313 dollars, against the 1,094 of the Nintendo twin in January. Six months later, on the same Nintendo theme from NES to Nintendo 64, the typical lot has grown by 20%.

Chart 9 · The nine 2026 Heritage sessions in chronological order: on the left the number of lots, on the right mean (dark bar) and median (light bar) on a logarithmic scale. In purple the session under review, in gray the others; 7452, 7453 and 7454 are Signature, the others Showcase; the median for 7452 is not available.
Chart 9 · The nine 2026 Heritage sessions in chronological order: on the left the number of lots, on the right mean (dark bar) and median (light bar) on a logarithmic scale. In purple the session under review, in gray the others; 7452, 7453 and 7454 are Signature, the others Showcase; the median for 7452 is not available.

The point. An auction of 131 lots with the flattest pyramid and the highest median of the year is the sign of a market that buys in depth. Nintendo collecting at 8 and 16 bits does not live on a single trophy: it lives on sixty boxes between one thousand and two thousand dollars that find a buyer every time.

Final thoughts: what this auction says to the collector

1. Production beats the grade. A first print Super Mario Bros. 6.0 worth 2.6 times a 9.4: on historic titles, the variant is the first thing to read, the number the second.

2. Black Box games have a stable price. Twelve complete black boxes with a median of 1,625 dollars and peaks up to 7,813: it is the most readable segment of NES collecting, and one of the few with a deep price list.

3. Japan is worth a premium. Thirteen Japanese lots with a median 33% higher than the American one, in an auction designed for a US audience: the first Japanese generation of Pokémon is now a benchmark even in Dallas.

The variant is the first thing to read. The rating the second.

An auction without a record, bringing in 230,000 dollars and placing 96 lots out of 131 above one thousand, is not a market in waiting: it is a market at work. In July 2026, certified Nintendo collecting showed its body, not its peak, and it is in the body that the prices that matter are formed. Cataloging, certifying, and exchanging this depth with the same rigor reserved for records is the work that The Games Market is building for Europe.

author

The Games Market Redazione

The Games Market is an international platform dedicated to contemporary video games and retro games. It offers market data, technological tools, and services such as TGM grading to help value and purchase video games with confidence.

TGMGrading

Grade your titles

Inspection, sub-grades, seal and display case: every grade comes with the method behind it, written down in full.

Marketplace

See what is for sale

Graded pieces only: grade and label in plain sight on every listing, so you know exactly what you are buying.