GRADE YOUR TITLE
Four tenths of a grade, three times the price
Grading

Four tenths of a grade, three times the price

by The Games Market RedazioneJanuary 23, 2026

Heritage Showcase 44343, January 2026: 104 Nintendo lots from the NES to Nintendo 64, two identical Pokémon Emerald copies worth 17,500 and 5,125 dollars, and a late-production Super Mario Bros. that beats the early ones. Nine charts and three tables to open the auction year.

The auction: the first auction of the year

Heritage Auctions' Showcase 44343, which closed on January 22, opens the 2026 calendar of video game auctions. It is a Nintendo-themed auction, from the NES to the Nintendo 64 with handhelds in between: 104 lots, proceeds of $181,267, an average of 1,743 and a median of 1,094. A note to provide context: Heritage is the major Texas auction house, prices are in dollars, the lots are almost all in U.S. editions and the buyers are largely American. We are reading it from Europe because the United States remains the reference market for video game collecting.

The catalog is that of the classic collector: 44 NES lots with the sealed Super Mario Bros. trilogy, 17 Nintendo 64, 15 Super Nintendo, 15 Game Boy, and a handful of Pokémon for Game Boy Advance that alone accounts for 14% of the auction. As always, we have reconstructed the auction lot by lot: title, platform, certification, and final bid for all 104 pieces are in the attached spreadsheet.

Table 1 · The figures summarizing session 44343. Values inclusive of the buyer’s premium.
Table 1 · The figures summarizing session 44343. Values inclusive of the buyer’s premium.

Performance: a lightweight peak, a broad body

The top lot weighs 10% of the take, the top three 19%, the top ten 37%. 63% of the money sits outside the top ten: a low pyramid, as in all the Showcases, with only one lot above ten thousand dollars.

Chart 1 · Share of total revenue by lot groups, from left: the first lot, lots from the second to the third, from the fourth to the tenth, all the others.
Chart 1 · Share of total revenue by lot groups, from left: the first lot, lots from the second to the third, from the fourth to the tenth, all the others.

The two central brackets divide the auction: 37 lots between one thousand and two thousand dollars and 18 between two and five thousand together account for 54% of the proceeds. Thirty-five lots are between five hundred and one thousand, seven below five hundred. Above five thousand there are seven pieces, two Pokémon, two Super Mario Bros., a Final Fantasy, an Ocarina of Time and an Emerald in 9.4, for 31%.

Chart 2 · Number of lots by award band; the thresholds in dollars separate the bands. Above each point, the share of revenue for the band.
Chart 2 · Number of lots by award band; the thresholds in dollars separate the bands. Above each point, the share of revenue for the band.

By platform, the Game Boy Advance is off the charts: four lots, three of them American Pokémon, with a median of 3,594 dollars. The Nintendo 64 stands at 1,625, the Super Nintendo at 1,188, the NES at 1,094. The Game Boy, fifteen lots, is the entry point: median 813 dollars.

Chart 3 · Median award by platform with at least three lots; in parentheses, the number of lots. The price of the typical lot, not the record one.
Chart 3 · Median award by platform with at least three lots; in parentheses, the number of lots. The price of the typical lot, not the record one.

The records: Emerald, the title worth an auction

17.500 dollars for Pokémon Emerald in Wata 9.8 A+, first-production “Only For” logo variant: the most expensive lot of the session and nearly a tenth of the proceeds. In the same auction, another Emerald, same variant, same production, in Wata 9.4 A+, stopped at 5,125. Four tenths of a grade, 3.4 times the price. It is the opposite lesson to that of black boxes: with modern and abundant titles, where the variant is the same for everyone, the grade once again takes command.

Chart 4 · The ten highest awards, on a logarithmic scale. In purple the titles, in magenta consoles and other objects.
Chart 4 · The ten highest awards, on a logarithmic scale. In purple the titles, in magenta consoles and other objects.

$17.500  Absolute record · Lot #79102. Pokémon Emerald Version, Wata 9.8 A+ Sealed, logo «Only For», first production run. Game Boy Advance, 2005. The third chapter of the Hoenn generation, in the grade the market pays the most for.

$9.375  Second · Lot #79073. Pokémon Yellow Version: Special Pikachu Edition, Wata 9.6 A+ Sealed, Pixel ESRB, first production. Game Boy, 1999. The yellow version of the first American Pokémon in the initial print run.

$7.813  Third · Lot #79032. Super Mario Bros., CGC 8.5 A+ Sealed, Oval SOQ R, last production. NES, 1985. Sealed beats complete: the two CIB copies of the same title, in Wata 9.0, stopped at 2,000 and 1,375.

Table 2 · The sixteen most expensive lots of the session, by hammer price.
Table 2 · The sixteen most expensive lots of the session, by hammer price.

The sagas. Pokémon accounts for 24% of the auction with nine lots for $43,594 and a median of 2,750; Mario 19% with fifteen lots for 34,194; Zelda 8% with seven lots for 14,688. The three Nintendo house sagas, plus the two Final Fantasy, together account for more than half of the takings. The rest is the third-party catalog in triple digits: Star Wars, Mega Man, Donkey Kong, Dragon Quest.

Chart 5 · Total awarded value by series, top seven; number of lots in parentheses.
Chart 5 · Total awarded value by series, top seven; number of lots in parentheses.

The same title, different prices: latest production, first price

The catalog offers near-perfect pairs. Two sealed Super Mario Bros. 2, both Wata 9.6 A+: the intermediate production with TM stamp brings in 5,250 dollars, the final production with R stamp and three-line warranty 3,750. Two Ocarina of Time: the Standard Release in 9.2 A++ brings in 5,500, the Collector’s Edition in 9.0 A 1,875. Two DuckTales: the sealed copy in CGC 9.0 brings in 1,688, the complete one in Wata 9.6 1,094.

Table 3 · Four pairs of twin lots: the vote on the Emerald, the production on the Mario, the variant on the Zelda, the seal on the DuckTales.
Table 3 · Four pairs of twin lots: the vote on the Emerald, the production on the Mario, the variant on the Zelda, the seal on the DuckTales.

The Super Mario Bros. case completes the picture from the other side. The sealed copy in CGC 8.5, although from the final production run, is worth $7,813; the two complete-in-box copies in Wata 9.0, one with a hangtab and one with an intermediate-production round sticker, fetch 2,000 and 1,375. An intact seal with an average grade is worth nearly four times an open box with a high grade. And Hurricanes for Super Nintendo, B+ seal and 9.0 grade, reaches $3,500 simply because it is one of the console’s hardest titles to find: when rarity is extreme, the market forgives the letter.

The cloud of ratings shows the consequence: between 9.0 and 9.8, prices overlap from 300 to 17,500 dollars. The rating orders copies of the same title, not titles among themselves.

Chart 6 · Each point is a lot: grade on the horizontal axis, price on a logarithmic scale. Filled circles are sealed items, empty circles are complete with box. On the left is the PSA, Wata, and CGC scale; on the right is the VGA scale. The colors indicate the grader: PSA purple, Wata magenta, CGC periwinkle, VGA deep purple.
Chart 6 · Each point is a lot: grade on the horizontal axis, price on a logarithmic scale. Filled circles are sealed items, empty circles are complete with box. On the left is the PSA, Wata, and CGC scale; on the right is the VGA scale. The colors indicate the grader: PSA purple, Wata magenta, CGC periwinkle, VGA deep purple.

Niches and Surprises: a 1990 championship and a gold console

The Nintendo World Championships. Two artifacts from the 1990 tournament, an unfilled participation certificate and the event’s yellow T-shirt, sold in the room for 575 and 525 dollars. They are the cheapest lots among the historic ones and the most curious at the auction: memorabilia from an event is worth less than a sealed common title.

The golden console. The exclusive Toys “R” Us gold Nintendo 64, in VGA 80 Qualified, fetches 3,250 dollars: the only console in the auction and the thirteenth sale, tied with F1 Pole Position for Game Boy in VGA 90, a minor racing title that surprised everyone.

The original art. The Bible Adventures cover sketches are priced at 1,375 dollars, those of Street Fighter 2010 signed by Greg Winters at 375; the cover of Frank Cirocco’s S.W.A.T.Pro magazine, featuring Super Double Dragon, is the cheapest lot in the session at 199 dollars. In January 2026, video game art is still worth less than the box it illustrates.

The grades: Wata’s auction

In the first Showcase of the year, the dominant grading company is Wata: 50 lots out of 104 and 57% of the proceeds, with the two Emeralds, the Pokémon Yellow and the Super Mario Bros. 2. VGA handles 25 lots, especially sealed Game Boy and Nintendo 64 items, for 20%; CGC 19 lots and 18%, with the Super Mario Bros. at 7,813 and the Pokémon Red at 4,125. PSA appears only once, with the Pokémon Gold at 2,750. Nine lots went through without certification.

Chart 7 · Awarded value by grading entity, with share and number of lots; the gray slice represents uncertified lots. In the center, total revenue and number of lots.
Chart 7 · Awarded value by grading entity, with share and number of lots; the gray slice represents uncertified lots. In the center, total revenue and number of lots.

Reading for TGM. The dominance of Wata in January, that of PSA in Signatures, that of VGA on the Japanese market: the American market does not have a single standard, it has one for each segment. An Emerald 9.8 worth 3.4 times a 9.4 says how much the grade matters when the variant is the same; a sealed Super Mario Bros. 8.5 that beats a complete 9.0 says how much the seal matters. It is the principle on which TGMGrading builds its own method: a documented and repeatable judgment that brings together grade, seal, and variant.

The origins: NES and Nintendo 64 make up 55%

The NES is worth $66,975 across 44 lots, 37% of the auction; the Nintendo 64 $32,063 across 17 lots, 18%. Then the Game Boy with $26,149 across 15 lots, the Game Boy Advance with $25,438 across four, the Super Nintendo with $20,581 across fifteen. The U.S. editions account for 98% of the proceeds: the three Japanese lots, Mother and Super Mario Bros. 3 for Famicom and a Pocket Monsters LeafGreen, are worth $3,500 in total.

Chart 8 · Awarded value by platform, with amount and number of lots; the area is proportional to the value. The dashed box groups the smaller platforms and the lots without a platform.
Chart 8 · Awarded value by platform, with amount and number of lots; the area is proportional to the value. The dashed box groups the smaller platforms and the lots without a platform.

The comparison: from January to July, the median rises

Arranged in sequence, the nine Heritage video game sessions of 2026 tell the story of two markets. The three Signature sales, 7452 in March, 7453 in June, and 7454 in August, range from two to five million dollars with averages between 6,000 and 32,000. The six Showcase sales, from January to September, range between 98,000 and 230,000 dollars with medians between 938 and 1,313. This one opens the series with a median of 1,094 dollars; the Nintendo twin in July, 44347, closes at 1,313 with more lots and higher proceeds. On the same theme, over six months, the typical lot rose by 20%.

Chart 9 · The nine Heritage sessions of 2026 in chronological order: on the left the number of lots, on the right mean (dark bar) and median (light bar) on a logarithmic scale. In purple the session under review, in gray the others; 7452, 7453 and 7454 are Signature, the others Showcase; the median for 7452 is not available.
Chart 9 · The nine Heritage sessions of 2026 in chronological order: on the left the number of lots, on the right mean (dark bar) and median (light bar) on a logarithmic scale. In purple the session under review, in gray the others; 7452, 7453 and 7454 are Signature, the others Showcase; the median for 7452 is not available.

The point. The first auction of the year sets the starting point: 104 lots, median 1,094, only one piece above ten thousand. Everything that came after, from the Signature records to July’s median, is measured from here.

Final considerations: what this auction says to the collector

1. In modern titles, the vote rules. Two identical Emeralds, 17,500 versus 5,125 dollars for four tenths: when variant and production match, the numerical scale comes back to decide, and it decides forcefully.

2. On classics, the seal rules. A sealed Super Mario Bros. in 8.5 is worth almost four times a complete copy in 9.0: the intact cellophane is the most expensive variable of the NES.

3. Rarity forgives the letter. Hurricanes in B+ at $3,500, while Tag Team Wrestling in B+ stops at 325: the same letter weighs differently depending on how many copies exist.

The vote orders the copies of the same title, not the titles among themselves.

An auction at 181,000 dollars that opens the year with a median of one thousand and three different rules for three segments is not a confused market: it is a market that has learned to distinguish. In January 2026, certified Nintendo collecting already knows that grade, seal, and variant do not have the same value on every title. Cataloging, certifying, and trading with this level of precision is the work The Games Market is building for Europe.

author

The Games Market Redazione

The Games Market is an international platform dedicated to contemporary video games and retro games. It offers market data, technological tools, and services such as TGM grading to help value and purchase video games with confidence.

TGMGrading

Grade your titles

Inspection, sub-grades, seal and display case: every grade comes with the method behind it, written down in full.

Marketplace

See what is for sale

Graded pieces only: grade and label in plain sight on every listing, so you know exactly what you are buying.